The Mechanisms of Guaranteeing the Right to Clean Air in Iran and International Documents

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

1 Department of Environmental Law, Science and Research Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran

2 Department of law, Islamic Azad University, Damavand Branch, Tehran, Iran

3 Department of Public& International Law, Faculty of Law, University of Qom, Qom, Iran

Abstract
Introduction: Air pollution is a major global environmental problem that has various adverse effects on health and the environment. Countries have come to the conclusion that the fight against this problem will only be possible through international cooperation. Therefore, taking measures to reform the existing structures based on scientific principles and applying the laws and experiences of other countries in the world to deal with air pollution are among the main priorities. The distinction of this research is to investigate the role of international guarantees and documents and Iranian laws in dealing with air pollution, so this research seeks to bridge the gap between domestic laws and documents in comparison with international laws.
Materials and Methods: The present study is in the group of applied research in terms of objectives and nature, and an analytical-descriptive method has been used in its conduct. First, these documents and laws were studied in the form of a library, then according to the questions and conceptual framework, the documents and laws in the national and international system were analyzed, and finally the documents and laws were implemented. To investigate the hypotheses, dialectics, which is one of the methods of scientific cognition (research), was used.
Results: In the environmental sector, the law of the Fifth Five-Year Plan is not sufficient and does not include comprehensive and long-term plans to achieve sustainable and appropriate development. The municipal law approved in 1955 has also not been able to play a significant role in the realization of the guarantee of the human right to clean air due to the lack of executive guarantees and up-to-dateness. The Environmental Protection and Improvement Act of 1974 also needs to be revised and amended due to the objective conditions of the post-revolutionary society and the flaws and inadequacies of the regulations. Although the penalty of fine in the Clean Air Law has increased in terms of amount compared to the previous law, unfortunately, it has less power than these perpetrators in the case of factories and legal entities that have more income. Regarding the performance of the Clean Air Act, it can be stated that out of the 56 articles stipulated in the Clean Air Law and its technical regulations, the implementation of 22 articles has been estimated to be poor, 17 to moderate, and 17 to be good. International instruments also lack a clear guarantee of implementation, and the mechanism provided for in the conventions seems to be very simple and inefficient.
Discussion: The laws and approvals related to air pollution have not been properly implemented, and this issue is more noticeable in the case of the Clean Air Act. The most important reasons for the lack of law enforcement are lack of financial resources, lack of priority to the issue of air pollution, lack of adequate and effective supervision, inconsistency between the executive agencies and island operations, personal interpretation of the law's texts, and finally, the flaws in the text of the law. According to the results of the present study, it can be acknowledged that in Iran, as a developing country, the issue of guaranteeing the right to clean air and its implementation mechanisms has not yet found its real place in the legal system. International instruments also lack a specific guarantee of performance such as reciprocity or specific contractual mechanisms. Due to the negative effects of air pollution on the health of citizens and the country's economy, urgent action to untie the existing knots over the implementation of the Clean Air Act is necessary and there must be a serious will in this regard.

Keywords

Subjects


  1. Abbasi, M. and Soudmandi., P., 2015. Human rights and the right to clean air, Bioethics Quarterly, (21)6. (In Persian with English abstract)
  2. Abdullahi, M., Mashhad, A. and Faradi, M., 2013. Rights of air protection, Tehran: Mezan Publishing(In Farsi).
  3. Abdollahi, M., Mashhadi, A. and Faryadi, M., 2012. Legal Evaluation of Standards for Air Pollution from Stationary SourcesEnvironmental Sciences10(2).
  4. Ahmadi Niaz, S., Zainelzadeh, R. and Raispour, R., 2018. Investigating the impact of the good ruling on environmental quality index in a selection of developing countries. Environmental Science and Technology 20(4), 17-165 (In Persian with English abstract)
  5. Arshad, K., Hussain, N., Ashraf, M.H., and Saleem, M.Z., 2024. Air pollution and climate change as grand challenges to sustainability. Science of The Total Environment, 172370.‏
  6. Amir-Arjomand, A. and Mashhadi, A., 2010. The Right to Clean Air and Related Sanctions in Iranian and French Law. TANAFFOS(Respiration)9(2(spiring), 7-12.
  7. Asgari, A., Mashadi, A. and Arashpour, A., 2023. The place of the right to clean air in international jurisprudence. Political Sociology of Iran,5(12), 1028-1047. (In Farsi).
  8. Babakhani, E., 2023. Environmental Crimes in the Measure of Restorative Justice: from Policies to Programs. Journal of Legal Research, 22(53), 443-468.‏
  9. Borja-Patiño, J., Robalino-López, A. and Mena-Nieto, A., 2024. Breaking the unsustainable paradigm: exploring the relationship between energy consumption, economic development and carbon dioxide emissions in Ecuador. Sustainability Science, 19(2), 403-421.‏
  10. Boyd, D.R., 2019. The Human Right to Breathe Clean Air. Annals of global health, 85(1), 146. https://doi.org/10.5334/aogh.2646
  11. Cooper, N., 2021. How the new human right to a healthy environment could accelerate New Zealand's action on climate change. The Conversation. Retrieved 2021-11-30.
  12. Ferdowsi, M., Porhashmi, S.M. and Maknoun. S.A., 2022. The comprehensive system of environmental assessments: a tool for the enforcement of preventive environmental rights. Journal of Sustainability, Development and Environment, 3(2), 113-128. (In Persian with English abstract)
  13. Ghasemi, A., Alavian, M., Lotfi, S. and Rahmani, M., 2021. Analysis of the themes of good urban governance in the development programs of the Islamic Republic of Iran, Strategic Researches of Social Issues, 10(3), pp. 117-141. doi: 10.22108/srspi.2021.130845.1736 (In Persian with English abstract)
  14. Gough, C.A., Chadwick, M.J., Biewald, B., Kuylenstierna, J.C.I., Bailey, P.D. and Cinderby, S., 1995. Developing optimal abatement strategies for the effects of sulphur and nitrogen deposition at European scale. Water, Air, and Soil Pollution, 85(4), 2601-2606.
  15. Hajzadeh, H., 2020. An analysis of the legal requirements of dealing with climate change from the perspective of international treaties and domestic laws. Climate Change Research 1(2), 55-78. (In Persian with English abstract)
  16. Halwani, S., 2022. The government's obligations towards citizens' right to enjoy healthy air in Iranian law, Journal of Civil Rights Studies, Volume 5, Number 19.
  17. Hamidi, F., Afshari, M. and Mashhadi., A., 2020. Mechanisms to guarantee the right to clean air in Iran and the European Union, Sustainability, Development and Environment, 3(3), 51-66 (In Persian with English abstract)
  18. Heydarzadeh, A., Vervaei, A., Pournuri M. and Ghasemi, N., 2022. Investigation of guarantees and legal requirements to deal with long-range and transboundary pollution (in the countries of the Middle East region in the form of regional understanding). Environmental Science and Technology, 23(6), 145-160 (In Persian with English abstract)
  19. Holgate, S.T., 2017. 'Every breath we take: the lifelong impact of air pollution' - a call for action. Clinical medicine (London, England), 17(1), 8–12. https://doi.org/10.7861/clinmedicine.17-1-8
  20. Jutterström, S., Moldan, F., Moldanová, J., Karl, M., Matthias, V. and Posch, M., 2021. The impact of nitrogen and sulfur emissions from shipping on the exceedance of critical loads in the Baltic Sea region. Atmospheric chemistry and physics, 21(20), 15827-15845.‏
  21. Karimi, D. and Mousavi Madani, N., 2016. Investigation of the effectiveness of laws and regulations governing air pollution in Iran, Journal of Environmental Science and Technology, 19 (4), 571-581. (In Persian with English abstract)
  22. Kleemola-Juntunen, P. and Kirchner, S., 2022. Gothenburg Protocol and Convention on Long-Range Transboundary Air Pollution. In Global Encyclopedia of Territorial Rights (pp. 1-8). Cham: Springer International Publishing.‏
  23. Lode, B., Schönberger, P. and Toussaint, P., 2016. ‘Clean Air for All by 2030? Air Quality in the 2030 Agenda and in International Law’, 25 Review of European, Comparative and International Environmental Law 27, 35.
  24. Mashhadi, A., 2025. Evolution of administrative and law enforcement tools to deal with air pollution; French law experience. Journal of Environmental Science Studies,9(4), 9450-9443. (In Farsi).
  25. Nasr Esfahani, A. and Raisi, L., 2016. The right to enjoy clean air in the procedure of international authorities of the journal: Comparative Law » Autumn and Winter 2016, 108, 89 to 106. (In Persian with English abstract)
  26. Norouzi, N., 2024. Ecopolitics to International Environmental Law: A Literature Review on How Countries Are Performing Under the International Convention on Climate Change. Eco-Politics and Global Climate Change, 43-58.‏
  27. Novello, D.P., 1992. United Nations: Protocol to the 1979 Convention on Long-Range Transboundary Air Pollution Concerning the Control of Emissions of Volatile Organic Compounds or their Transboundary Fluxes. International Legal Materials, 31(3), 568-611.
  28. Piran, F. and Piran, H., 2020. Investigating transportation and traffic problems and how to manage them in developing cities with an emphasis on Islamshahr. Magazine: Architecture, third year, summer 2019, number 15. (In Persian with English abstract)
  29. Pourhashemi, A. and Parandeh Motlatl, A., 2021. Investigating the position and role of the conference of members of environmental treaties in the development of international environmental law, environmental science and technology 22(11), 171-181. (In Persian with English abstract)
  30. Pourhashemi, A., Sobhani Nia, M. and Ziadkhani., S., 2022. Analyzing the nature of governments' commitments in the 2015 Paris Agreement on climate change. Environmental Science and Technology 23(11), 85-98 (In Persian with English abstract)
  31. Protocol, A., 1998. Protocol on Heavy Metals to the Convention on Long-range Transboundary Air Pollution.
  32. Rashedi, M. and Mashhadi, A., 2024. An Analysis of the Approach of Development Programs of the Islamic Republic of Iran to Air Protection. Public Law Studies Quarterly54(2), 985-999.
  33. Rajamani, L., Jeffery, L., Höhne, N., Hans, F., Glass, A., Ganti, G. and Geiges, A., 2021. National ‘fair shares’ in reducing greenhouse gas emissions within the principled framework of international environmental law. Climate Policy, 21(8), 983–1004. https://doi.org/10.1080/14693062.2021.1970504
  34. Rayfuse, R., Jaeckel, A. and Klein, N., 2023. International marine environmental law in the 21st century. In Research Handbook on International Marine Environmental Law (pp. 2-32). Edward Elgar Publishing.‏
  35. Riazi, M., Faqih, H., Mashhadhi, A. and Mansourpour, N., 2023. Examining the rights and obligations of intergenerational justice in order to achieve the goals of sustainable development "with emphasis on the 50 principles of the Iranian Constitution". Journal of Environmental Science and Technology, 25(2), 41-53. (In Persian with English abstract)
  36. Rönnberg, D., 2020. The Right to Breathe: An Examination of How Human Rights Can Be Applied to Guarantee Access to Clean Air.‏
  37. Sabouripour, M. and Haji Vand, A., 2017. Analysis of air pollution in the clean air law approved in 2016, 7th National Conference on Air and Noise Management, Tehran. (In Farsi).
  38. Sadeghi, H., Yazdanpanah, R., Amir Arjamand, A. and Mazini, A., 2018. Evaluation of the effectiveness of the Kyoto Protocol in reducing greenhouse gas emissions (from the perspective of environmental economics). Quarterly Journal of Environmental Economics and Natural Resources; 3 (6), 115-142. (In Persian with English abstract)
  39. Shamei, M., 2015. Government obligations and the right to clean air, master's thesis, Shahid Beheshti University.
  40. Shindell, d. et al., 2018. “Quantified, localized health benefits of accelerated carbon dioxide emissions reductions”. Nature Climate Change. 2011; 8(4): 291–295. DOI: 10.1038/s41558-018-0108-y
  41. Soodmandi, M., 2022. Flaws and weaknesses of the Clean Air Law compared to the Law on How to Prevent Air Pollution, Public Law Research, 22(68), 141-170, (In Persian with English abstract)
  42. Suman, A.B., 2021. Citizen sensing from a legal standpoint: Legitimizing the practice under the Aarhus framework. Journal for European Environmental & Planning Law, 18(1-2), 8-38.‏
  43. United States Environmental Protection Agency. The Benefits and Costs of the Clean Air Act from 1990 to 2020 (Washington, D.C.). World Bank and Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation. 2016. The Cost of Air Pollution: Strengthening the Economic Case for Action (Washington, D.C.). D. Shindell et al., 2018. “Quantified, localized health benefits of accelerated carbon dioxide emissions reductions”. Nature Climate Change. 2011; 8(4): 291–295. DOI: 10.1038/s41558-018-0108-y
  44. United States Environmental Protection Agency., 2019. The Benefits and Costs of the Clean Air Act from 1990 to 2020 (Washington, D.C.).
  45. UNICEF and World Health Organization Joint Monitoring Programme. Progress on household drinking water, sanitation and hygiene 2000–2017. 2019.
  46. Wu, D., Xie, Y. and Liu, D., 2023. Rethinking the complex effects of the clean energy transition on air pollution abatement: Evidence from China's coal-to-gas policy. Energy, 283, 128413.‏
  47. Zahar, A., 2022. Human Rights Law and the Obligation to Reduce Greenhouse Gas Emissions. Human Rights Review, 23(3), 385-411.‏
  48. Zahedi, A. and Khodakarmi, N., 2015. Analysis and investigation of air pollution crime in Iranian cities from the point of view of criminal law and international conventions. New Perspectives in Human Geography (Human Geography), 11 (4), 159-183.
  49. Zhang, Q. et al, ‘Transboundary Health Impacts of Transported Global Air Pollution and International Trade’ 2017. 543 Nature 705; V Ramanathan and Y Feng, ‘Air Pollution, Greenhouse Gases and Climate Change: Global and Regional Perspectives’ (2009) 43 Atmospheric Environment 37. M Sand et al, ‘Response of Arctic Temperature to Changes in Emissions of Short-Lived Climate Forcers’ (2016) 6 Nature Climate Change 286.