Qualitative Analysis of the Factors Influencing Rural Residents’ Support for Water Resource Management Policies: A Paradigmatic Model

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

1 University of Mazandaran

2 University Of Mazandaran

10.22034/envj.2026.598718.1672
Abstract
Introduction: The water crisis in rural areas, particularly in the agricultural sector, is not solely attributable to the physical scarcity of water resources; rather, it is associated with a range of economic, social, institutional, and policy-related factors. In this regard, the extent to which rural residents support and cooperate with water resources management policies plays an important role in determining their success or failure. Despite the significance of this issue, the processes through which rural residents develop support for or opposition to such policies, as well as the interactions among the factors influencing these responses, have received limited attention. This study aimed to identify and explain the factors affecting rural residents’ support for water resources management policies in eastern Mazandaran Province. Protection Motivation Theory was also employed as a sensitizing framework to understand and interpret the underlying perceptual and behavioral processes.

Materials and Methods: This qualitative study employed the grounded theory approach. Data were collected through in-depth, semi-structured interviews with 20 rural residents and experts from the Mazandaran Regional Water Company, the Agricultural Jihad Organization, and the Farmers’ House in Behshahr, Neka, and Galugah counties during 2025 and 2026. Participants were selected through purposive sampling, and the data were analyzed using open, axial, and selective coding. During axial coding, the categories were organized within a paradigmatic model comprising causal conditions, contextual conditions, intervening conditions, strategies, and consequences. To assess inter-coder agreement, 20% of the interviews were independently coded by a second researcher, yielding a Cohen’s kappa coefficient of 0.82.

Results: The findings revealed that economic and livelihood pressures, perceived justice and policy legitimacy, and institutional trust constituted the causal conditions influencing rural residents’ support. Contextual conditions included environmental conditions, structural factors, water governance, and awareness and education, while intervening conditions comprised social capital, rural culture, and identity and lifestyle. In response to these conditions, rural residents adopted strategies such as covert resistance, problem denial, conditional support, changes in cropping patterns, and alternative livelihoods. These strategies were associated with consequences including the exacerbation of the water crisis, policy failure, and increased conflicts. Furthermore, the concepts of Protection Motivation Theory, including perceived severity and vulnerability, self-efficacy, response efficacy, and response costs, were used to interpret the perceptual and behavioral dimensions of the findings.

Discussion: The findings indicate that rural residents’ support for water resources management policies is not determined solely by their awareness of the water crisis or the severity of water scarcity. Rather, it is shaped by the interaction between perceived threat and coping capacity, alongside economic conditions, perceived justice, institutional trust, and social and cultural contexts. Accordingly, when water resources management policies are incompatible with rural residents’ livelihood requirements or are not perceived as fair, legitimate, and trustworthy, support for these policies becomes fragile, increasing the likelihood of covert resistance and other forms of non-cooperation. Therefore, the effectiveness of water resources management policies requires simultaneous attention to their economic, perceptual, institutional, and cultural dimensions, as well as efforts to strengthen trust and justice throughout the policymaking process. These findings highlight the need to design policies that are responsive to local conditions and to ensure the active participation of rural communities in decision-making processes.

Keywords: Water Resources Management; Policy Support; Rural Residents; Grounded Theory; Protection Motivation Theory; Environmental Behavior.

Keywords

Subjects


Articles in Press, Accepted Manuscript
Available Online from 16 November 2026